Mel’s Mexican Chicken Casserole

4 comments In the spirit of transparency, I do receive commission from mentioning some of the products in this post. Any commission I earn comes at no additional cost to you and I’ll never recommend products that I don’t use, love and believe in.

Jump to Recipe

For those of you who join us for our weekly Weight Watchers chats, you’ll remember this recipe from Chat #182 (and you’ve probably been waiting anxiously for this recipe!)

My best friend, Melanie, shared this beautiful creation with us and boy was it good! Unfortunately, it was so tasty because it was loaded with not-so-point-conscious ingredients. And although I have to admit that I indulged and enjoyed this dish and it’s leftovers for a few days, I resolved to find a way to swap out the ingredients in this recipe using lower point ingredients.

The original recipe called for things like cream cheese (at 72 SP in two blocks I had to find a smart swap for this), salsa, rice (14 SP), 1 cup shredded cheese (16 SP), a tbsp of butter to grease the pan, and more. All in all, it came out to 10 SP on My WW Green per serving. Check Blue & Purple for points (you could swap out brown rice on Purple!)

Mel's Mexican Chicken Casserole
Mel’s Mexican Chicken Casserole

Many of these ingredients have simple, SP-friendly alternatives so with my Recipe Swap Out printable in hand, I got to work creating a “swapped out” copycat version.

Mel's Mexican Chicken Casserole

Prep

Cook

Total

Yield 12 servings

Ingredients

Sauce:

Casserole:

  • 10 oz. bag of riced cauliflower
  • Sliced peppers and onions, cooked
  • Cilantro, to taste
  • 3 grilled chicken breasts, cubed and precooked (or precooked frozen chicken)
  • 1 cup of your favorite shredded cheese (or Daiya shreds for a vegan option)
  • Nonstick spray

Instructions

Sauce: Combine room temperature cream cheese and pineapple salsa and stir until smooth

Casserole:

  1. Preheat oven to 350°
  2. Spray a 9x13 pan, with nonstick cooking spray
  3. For the first layer, spread riced cauliflower evenly on the bottom of the pan
  4. For the second layer, evenly spread peppers and onions on top of the cauliflower and add cilantro to taste
  5. For the third layer, add your chicken on top of the peppers, onions, and cilantro
  6. Top with sauce mixture and shredded cheese (or Diaya shreds)
  7. Bake for 30 minutes or until cheese is melted and bubbly on top

Courses Dinner

Cuisine Mexican


Don’t forget to send some Love Bucks! Kc and I do this for free but there are fees associated with keeping the Egg Love coming. Please send Love Bucks by:
♥ Liking
♥ Sharing
♥ Commenting
♥ My favorite… Subscribing!
♥ And if you see something you like or want from one of our affiliate sponsors please order it while you are here! Be sure to check out my recommendations page for the products I mention in my posts and chats.

4 Comments

  1. If I swap brown rice is it 10 oz cooked or 10 oz uncooked?

  2. Do you know if this will freeze well? I will be the only one eating this and even if I make half the recipe, I will have some leftovers 🙂

    • Oh I don’t know if you’ll have leftovers hahaha! I think it would freeze well if you let it completely cool. Maybe don’t add the cilantro until you reheat it. John asked for it for breakfast and then dinner again tonight!